Badger 5 vs Badger 500 vs Badger 5XL Garbage Disposals: Ultimate Comparison
In this Badger 5 vs Badger 500 vs Badger 5XL comparison, all three models are mechanically identical—same motor, same chamber, same grinding system, same dimensions, and same performance.
The only differences are where you buy them and how long the warranty lasts.
What Are the Differences Between Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL?
The Differences (Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL)
| Feature | Badger 5 | Badger 500 | Badger 5XL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sold at | Amazon, Best Buy, most retailers | Amazon, Best Buy, most retailers | Lowe’s and official site |
| Warranty | 2 years | 3 years | 5 years |
Same Features Comparison
| Feature | Badger 5 | Badger 500 | Badger 5XL |
|---|---|---|---|
| Motor Power | 1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor | 1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor | 1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor |
| Grinding Speed (RPM) | 1725 RPM | 1725 RPM | 1725 RPM |
| Feed Type | Continuous Feed | Continuous Feed | Continuous Feed |
| Grinding Chamber Capacity | 26 oz | 26 oz | 26 oz |
| Overall Dimensions (HxW) | 11.5 in x 6.31 in | 11.5 in x 6.31 in | 11.5 in x 6.31 in |
| Mounting System | 3-bolt mount | 3-bolt mount | 3-bolt mount |
| Construction Materials | Galvanized Steel | Galvanized Steel | Galvanized Steel |
| Noise Insulation | Basic, no advanced sound insulation | Basic, no advanced sound insulation | Basic, no advanced sound insulation |
| Power Cord Included | No (sold separately) | No (sold separately) | No (sold separately) |
| Reset Button | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Hex Hole for Manual Rotation | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Exclusive Retailers | Amazon | Amazon | Exclusive to Lowe’s |
Which One Should You Buy?
- If you shop online (Amazon, etc.): Get Badger 5 or 500. They’re the same disposal, except the Badger 5 has a 2-year warranty while the Badger 500 includes a 3-year warranty.
- If you shop at Lowe’s:Â Get the Badger 5XL. Same disposal, with 5 years of warranty.
The price difference is typically $10-$20 between the standard and exclusive versions. If the exclusive is the same price or cheaper (holiday sale, clearance), grab it for the extra warranty year.
Conclusion
Do not overthink this comparison. These are the same disposals sold through different stores. Pick whichever is cheapest or most convenient to buy. If prices are similar, choose the longer warranty — Badger 500 (3 years) or Badger 5XL (5 years) over the Badger 5’s 2-year warranty.
If you want a genuinely better disposal, step up to the Badger 5XP (3/4 HP) or a Waste King L-2600 with stainless steel grind components.
FAQ’s
The Author
Muhammad Nabeel Dar is the founder of GarbageWasteDisposal.com and an SEO researcher focused on creating informational resources about garbage disposals and kitchen appliances. His work involves researching appliance performance, analyzing user questions, and structuring helpful guides that simplify complex kitchen appliance topics. Through this website, he shares researched insights to help homeowners better understand appliance maintenance, product comparisons, and everyday kitchen solutions.
