Badger 5 vs Badger 500 vs Badger 5XL Garbage Disposals: Ultimate Comparison

When it comes to choosing the right garbage disposal for your kitchen, InSinkErator’s Badger line often stands out as a popular choice for homeowners. The three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — all look very similar in design, size, and even performance, which can make it confusing to decide which one is right for you. So, how are they different, and why should you care?

What Are the Differences Between Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL?

It might seem that Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are almost identical at first glance. They share the same motor power, grinding speed, and even dimensions. But, here’s the catch: these models are actually branded differently depending on where they’re sold. Badger 500 is typically found at Home Depot, while Badger 5XL is exclusive to Lowe’s. The Badger 5 is available across multiple retailers, including Amazon. Despite this difference in branding, all three models offer the same performance and features.

Why does this matter for homeowners? Well, even though the models are technically the same, the price can vary based on where you buy them. Understanding these subtle branding differences can help you save a few bucks without compromising on quality. The key is to focus on what works best for your household in terms of performance, installation, and budget rather than getting caught up in the names.

Choosing the right model boils down to understanding what you need from a garbage disposal. For a small household, the Badger 5 might be more than sufficient. However, for those who prefer buying from a specific retailer, or perhaps want a model that’s exclusive to Lowe’s or Home Depot, the 500 and 5XL provide the same reliability and features. In the end, all three models are solid choices for homeowners looking for a cost-effective and efficient garbage disposal solution.

Comparison of Badger 5 with Badger 500 & Badger 5XL

Feature	Badger 5	Badger 500	Badger 5XL
Motor Power	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor
Grinding Speed (RPM)	1725 RPM	1725 RPM	1725 RPM
Feed Type	Continuous Feed	Continuous Feed	Continuous Feed
Grinding Chamber Capacity	26 oz	26 oz	26 oz
Overall Dimensions (HxW)	11.5 in x 6.31 in	11.5 in x 6.31 in	11.5 in x 6.31 in
Mounting System	3-bolt mount	3-bolt mount	3-bolt mount
Construction Materials	Galvanized Steel	Galvanized Steel	Galvanized Steel
Noise Insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation
Power Cord Included	No (sold separately)	No (sold separately)	No (sold separately)
Reset Button	Yes	Yes	Yes
Hex Hole for Manual Rotation	Yes	Yes	Yes
Warranty	3-year in-home warranty	3-year in-home warranty	3-year in-home warranty
Exclusive Retailer	Available across multiple retailers	Exclusive to Home Depot	Exclusive to Lowe’s

Performance

When it comes to performance, all three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — are equipped with the same 1/2 horsepower (HP) motor. This motor is a Dura-Drive induction motor that operates at 1725 RPM (revolutions per minute), providing solid grinding power for most household food waste. While the 1/2 HP motor is considered standard for smaller households, it’s still powerful enough to handle common food scraps like fruit peels, vegetable remnants, and small bones.

One thing to note is that while the 1725 RPM grinding speed may seem slower compared to some rival brands that use higher RPMs, the induction motor in these Badger models is known for delivering reliable, consistent torque at these speeds. This means you’re still getting good grinding power even at lower speeds, making these disposals dependable for everyday use. If you’re a family of two or three, this motor power is more than enough to handle your kitchen waste efficiently.

Learn more about what not to put down your garbage disposal to keep it functioning smoothly.

Feed Type

All three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — are continuous feed garbage disposals. What does that mean? Simply put, you can keep adding food waste into the disposal while it’s running, without having to stop and wait. This makes it convenient, especially when cleaning up after meals, as you can continuously scrape plates, peel vegetables, or dump leftovers directly into the disposal while it’s still grinding.

Continuous feed models like these are great for busy households because they let you work faster and more efficiently. The only thing you need to watch out for is making sure you don’t overload the disposal with large chunks of food at once, as that could cause it to jam. Still, this feed type is the most commonly preferred for modern kitchens due to its ease of use.

Grinding Chamber Capacity

The grinding chamber capacity of all three models is identical at 26 oz. While this might seem like a small number, it’s important to remember that because these disposals are continuous feed models, the grinding chamber size doesn’t play as big of a role in limiting the amount of food waste you can process. Since you can keep feeding waste into the disposal as it grinds, you’re not limited by the chamber’s capacity like you would be with batch feed disposals.

However, it’s worth noting that because the grinding chamber isn’t huge, it’s best to avoid adding large amounts of food waste all at once. Scrape smaller portions of food into the disposal to prevent clogging or jamming, especially if you’re dealing with tougher materials like potato peels or fibrous vegetables. For most households, the 26 oz capacity is more than sufficient for daily use.

Overall Dimensions

When it comes to dimensions, all three models share the same compact size, making them a convenient choice for homes with limited under-sink space. Each unit stands at 11.5 inches tall with a maximum width of 6.3125 inches. This uniformity in size is particularly useful if you’re looking to replace one model with another — say, if you’re switching from a Badger 5 to a Badger 500 — because the identical dimensions mean you won’t need to make any adjustments to your existing plumbing setup.

The compact size of these models also makes installation easier, especially in kitchens where space under the sink is tight. If you have a deep sink or limited cabinet space, these disposals will fit without requiring major adjustments. The 3-bolt mounting system that all three models use also simplifies the installation process, making it easier to twist and lock the unit into place. This size and mounting flexibility make the Badger models a popular choice for homeowners who want hassle-free installation without sacrificing functionality.

Installation and User-Friendliness

Installation Process for Each Model

Installing any of the Badger models — Badger 5, Badger 500, or Badger 5XL — is a relatively straightforward process, especially if you’re comfortable with basic DIY tasks. These disposals all use the same 3-bolt mounting system, which makes installation a breeze. This twist-and-lock mechanism allows you to easily secure the unit under your sink without much fuss.

Here’s a quick step-by-step guide on how to install these garbage disposals:

1. Turn off the power: Always start by switching off the power to the kitchen’s garbage disposal outlet. You can either unplug the existing unit or turn off the circuit breaker.
2. Remove the old disposal: If you’re replacing an existing unit, you’ll need to disconnect it first. Use a wrench to loosen the mounting bolts and remove the disposal from the mounting assembly. Detach the unit from the plumbing and the dishwasher hose if connected.
3. Prepare the new unit: For each Badger model, check if the power cord is pre-installed (it usually costs extra). If not, you’ll need to wire the unit yourself by connecting the wires to the disposal.
4. Install the mounting hardware: If you’re replacing an old Badger model, you can use the same 3-bolt mount, which saves time. If not, install the new mount by applying plumber’s putty to the flange and securing it with the mounting ring and screws.
5. Attach the disposal: Once the mounting hardware is secured, lift the disposal unit and align it with the mounting ring. Make sure the unit is locked into place by turning it clockwise.
6. Connect plumbing: Reattach the drainpipe and, if necessary, the dishwasher hose to the disposal’s outlet.
7. Test for leaks: Before finishing up, check for any leaks by running water through the sink while the disposal is turned off.
8. Restore power: Plug the disposal back in or flip the circuit breaker back on, and test the unit to ensure it’s working properly.

Overall, the installation process for the Badger 5, 500, and 5XL is quite similar due to their shared mounting systems and dimensions. If you’re replacing one of these models with another, the process is especially easy since you don’t need to adjust the plumbing or mount. Most homeowners can handle this installation on their own, though some may prefer professional help for wiring the power cord.

Proper installation is critical. If you face any challenges during the process, you might be interested in knowing who should install a garbage disposal, a plumber or an electrician.

Plumbing and Electrical Compatibility

All three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — are compatible with standard kitchen plumbing systems, which means you won’t need to make major adjustments during installation. The disposals are designed to fit most sinks with a standard drain outlet size, so they should integrate seamlessly with your existing plumbing. Additionally, the units come with a dishwasher connection, making them ideal for kitchens where the dishwasher drains into the garbage disposal.

In terms of electrical compatibility, these disposals typically don’t come with pre-installed power cords, though you can purchase one separately. If you’re replacing an older unit that already has a power cord, you can reuse it, but if not, you’ll need to wire a new one. This requires connecting the wires inside the unit, which is a simple task but may feel a bit intimidating if you’re not used to electrical work. For those unsure about wiring, hiring a professional to handle this part can provide peace of mind.

Construction, Durability, and Noise Levels

Construction Materials

The construction materials used in these garbage disposals are another area where the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are identical. All three models feature grinding components made of galvanized steel. While galvanized steel is rust-resistant and durable enough for daily use, it’s not as long-lasting or corrosion-resistant as stainless steel.

That said, galvanized steel still provides good value for the price, making these models a reliable and budget-friendly choice for most households. While it’s not the top-tier material you’d find in more expensive disposals, it gets the job done and ensures that the grinding chamber and components can handle typical food waste without damage.

If you’re looking for a disposal that will last longer and resist corrosion better, you might need to explore higher-end models with stainless steel components. However, for typical use in small to medium households, the construction of the Badger 5, 500, and 5XL is more than adequate.

Noise Insulation

Noise insulation is one area where budget-friendly models like the Badger 5, 500, and 5XL tend to cut corners. None of these models are equipped with advanced sound insulation features, meaning they are relatively louder than more premium disposals. However, the induction motor used in these models tends to run a bit quieter than the permanent magnet motors found in some rival brands, providing a more pleasant sound while operating.

While they won’t be whisper-quiet, these disposals are generally quieter than some of their competitors in the same price range. If reducing noise is a priority for you, you may want to consider upgrading to a more expensive model that includes advanced noise-dampening features, but keep in mind that this will come at a higher cost. For most users, the noise level of these Badger models will be perfectly acceptable for daily kitchen use.

Maintenance, Reset Buttons, and Power Cords

Maintenance and Common Issues

Maintaining your Badger 5, Badger 500, or Badger 5XL is relatively easy and straightforward. These models are designed for durability, but like any appliance, regular maintenance can extend their lifespan and ensure optimal performance. Here are some best practices for keeping your garbage disposal in top condition:

1. Run Cold Water While Operating: Always run cold water when the disposal is in use. By solidifying grease and fats with cold water, the grinding components can be kept free of clogs caused by grease and fats.
2. Avoid Non-Disposal Friendly Foods: While the Badger models can handle most kitchen waste, avoid putting hard or fibrous items like bones, corn husks, or large amounts of starchy foods like potato peels into the disposal. These can jam the grinding components or cause clogs in your plumbing.
3. Clean Regularly: To prevent bad odors and keep the grinding chamber clean, grind small pieces of citrus fruit peels, such as lemons or oranges, or ice cubes with a little baking soda. This helps to freshen the disposal and dislodge any stuck particles.
4. Check for Jams: If the unit stops working or you hear it hum without grinding, it’s likely jammed. Avoid turning it back on repeatedly, as this can overload the motor. Instead, use the reset button or manually rotate the impellers using the hex hole (discussed below).

Common Issues:

• Clogs: Overloading the disposal with too much food waste at once or attempting to grind non-disposal-friendly items can lead to clogs. Prevent this by feeding waste gradually.
• Jamming: Occasionally, hard food scraps or foreign objects can jam the disposal. In such cases, manually rotating the impellers can usually fix the issue.
• Odors: Foul smells can develop over time if food particles are stuck in the grinding chamber. Regular cleaning with citrus peels or baking soda can prevent this.

Reset Buttons and Power Cords

All three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — come equipped with a reset button. The reset button is located on the bottom-facing side of each unit and is used to reset the disposal if it becomes overloaded or jammed.

If the unit shuts off unexpectedly or begins to hum without grinding, the reset button is the first thing you should check. After turning the unit off and allowing it to cool, press the reset button to restore power to the motor. This can often resolve minor issues without requiring professional help.

Additionally, there’s a hex hole on the bottom of each unit that allows you to manually rotate the impellers to clear any jams. Using the included hex key (or an Allen wrench), insert the tool into the hole and turn it to manually dislodge any debris.

Regarding power cords, these models do not typically come with a pre-installed cord. Instead, the power cord must be purchased separately and wired into the unit. This gives you flexibility in how you install the unit, but if you’re replacing an existing model, you may be able to reuse the old cord. Keep in mind, hiring an electrician or professional installer can make the process easier if you’re not comfortable handling the wiring yourself.

Warranty and Long-Term Value

Warranty Comparison

In terms of warranty, the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL offer identical coverage. Each model comes with a 3-year in-home warranty, which covers both parts and labor. An InSinkErator technician will come to your home to repair or replace the disposal if it malfunctions within the warranty period.

The warranty period for these models is fairly standard for this price range, though some higher-end disposals may offer longer warranties. One benefit of this in-home warranty is that you won’t need to uninstall the unit and ship it back for repairs, which is a convenient feature for busy homeowners. It’s worth noting that older versions of the Badger 5 and 500 came with shorter warranties, but the current models all include the full 3-year coverage.

Customer support experiences for InSinkErator tend to be positive, with quick response times and helpful service representatives. This adds to the overall appeal of the brand, especially if you’re concerned about maintenance or repairs down the line.

Value for Money

When evaluating value for money, all three models — Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL — deliver similar performance at a reasonable price. The main difference between them comes down to branding and availability. The Badger 500 is typically exclusive to Home Depot, while the Badger 5XL is sold through Lowe’s. Despite this, all three models share the same features and specifications, so the choice between them will likely depend on where you prefer to shop or which retailer offers the best deal at the time of purchase.

Given their shared specifications, the price difference is minimal and usually depends on retailer pricing or promotions. All three models are budget-friendly and well-suited for households that need a reliable, no-frills garbage disposal. Compared to premium models that may offer additional features like stainless steel components or advanced noise insulation, the Badger line stands out as an affordable option that still provides strong performance and durability.

For homeowners looking for a solid garbage disposal without spending a fortune, the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL offer great long-term value. With proper maintenance and use, these disposals can last well beyond their 3-year warranty period, making them a smart investment for everyday kitchen use.

Noise Insulation and User Experience

In terms of noise insulation, the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are all budget models, so they lack the advanced sound-reducing technology found in more premium disposals. None of these models come equipped with specialized sound insulation features, so if you’re expecting a quiet disposal, these may not meet those expectations.

That said, the noise level isn’t unbearable. All three models use induction motors, which tend to be quieter and smoother than the permanent magnet motors found in some competing brands. While they won’t be whisper-quiet, most users find the noise level tolerable for everyday use. This means that while you will hear the disposal running, it’s unlikely to be disruptive, especially in smaller or enclosed kitchens.

Real-Life User Experiences and Feedback

User feedback on noise levels is mixed but leans toward positive. Many homeowners report that while the disposals aren’t the quietest, they’re quieter than expected for a budget-friendly option. Some users point out that the noise is more like a low hum rather than the loud grinding sound that comes from some other disposals, thanks to the induction motor.

That being said, if you have an open-concept kitchen or a particularly quiet home, you might notice the sound more. For those looking for a truly quiet experience, more premium InSinkErator models like the Evolution series would be a better fit, though they come at a higher price point. Overall, most users feel the noise level is manageable for the price, with only occasional complaints about louder-than-expected operation.

---

Power and Performance in the Kitchen

The Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL all come equipped with the same 1/2 horsepower Dura-Drive induction motor, providing consistent grinding power at 1725 RPM. While the motor power is the same across all three models, how they perform in the kitchen depends largely on the type of waste you’re grinding and the size of your household.

For small to medium households, these disposals are more than capable of handling typical kitchen waste like fruit and vegetable scraps, coffee grounds, and even small bones. However, the 1/2 HP motor does have its limitations. If you’re dealing with tougher food waste like fibrous vegetables (celery, corn husks) or larger amounts of waste, you may experience some strain on the motor. It’s important to avoid overloading the disposal or feeding in large amounts of food waste all at once, as this can lead to jamming.

Which Model is Better for Heavy-Duty Use or Larger Households?

While the Badger 5, 500, and 5XL are great for smaller households or occasional use, they may not be the best fit for heavy-duty use or larger families. If you regularly produce large amounts of food waste or deal with tougher food items, you might find that a more powerful model, such as one with a 3/4 or 1 HP motor, would suit your needs better.

For example, if you have a family of four or more and cook regularly, upgrading to a higher horsepower disposal, like the InSinkErator Evolution series, may provide better performance and longevity. That being said, the Badger models still perform well for standard kitchen tasks and will meet the needs of most households without any major issues.

Conclusion: Which One Should You Buy?

Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL are mostly dependent on where you shop rather than performance differences. These three models are nearly identical in terms of motor power, grinding capability, and overall features. The main distinction is that the Badger 5 is widely available at multiple retailers, while the Badger 500 is typically sold through Home Depot, and the Badger 5XL is exclusive to Lowe’s.

For most households, the performance and functionality of these models will meet your needs. The Badger 5 offers flexibility in terms of where you can purchase it, while the Badger 500 and 5XL are best for those loyal to specific retailers. In terms of power and noise levels, all three models provide similar results, making them a solid choice for small to medium households looking for a reliable, budget-friendly garbage disposal. However, if you prioritize a quieter unit or need more power for heavier kitchen use, you may want to consider premium options with higher horsepower and additional noise insulation.

For households with fewer members or standard kitchen waste, any of the three Badger models would be an excellent choice. To get the best deal, it’s worth comparing prices across retailers and choosing the most affordable option. If you have a larger household or frequently generate a significant amount of food waste, upgrading to a higher horsepower model, such as those in the InSinkErator Evolution series, may provide better performance and longevity. In the end, whichever model you choose, you’re getting a dependable and well-regarded garbage disposal that aligns with your household’s needs and budget, ensuring good value for your investment.