Badger 5 vs Badger 500 vs Badger 5XL Garbage Disposals: Ultimate Comparison

InSinkErator’s Badger line is one of the most trusted names in kitchen waste management, known for its blend of reliability, simplicity, and affordability. Over the years, it has become a household name for those seeking effective garbage disposals without breaking the bank. However, with several very similar models such as the Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL available, it can be confusing for shoppers to identify which one truly fits their needs.

This guide aims to clear up the confusion by providing a detailed breakdown of features, an honest look at pros and cons, and smart buying tips that will help you make a confident, informed decision tailored to your kitchen’s demands.

What Are the Differences Between Badger 5, Badger 500, and Badger 5XL?

Badger 5: The Proven Workhorse

The Badger 5 features a dependable 1/2 HP induction motor spinning at 1725 revolutions per minute, delivering solid grinding power for typical kitchen waste. Made from galvanized steel, its sturdy build stands up well to everyday use, making it a reliable partner for families.

This model is best suited for households with moderate food waste, offering a great balance between performance and price. Because it’s widely available and well supported with replacement parts, it remains a top pick among consumers upgrading from older disposals or installing a unit for the first time.

Badger 500: Home Depot’s Exclusive Take

Mechanically similar to the Badger 5, the Badger 500 is essentially a Home Depot-exclusive version boasting the same 1/2 HP motor and galvanized steel construction. Where the 500 stands out most is in the warranty department, offering a full three years of coverage compared to the 5’s two.

Having that extra year can provide peace of mind, especially in busy kitchens. Being sold only at Home Depot, this model also benefits from that retailer’s customer service policies and promotional deals, which may tip the scales in its favor for shoppers loyal to that chain or looking for a better warranty.

Badger 5XL: Lowe’s Exclusive with Premium Touches

The Badger 5XL mirrors the key mechanical specs of the other two models, featuring the familiar 1/2 HP motor and galvanized steel housing. Exclusively sold at Lowe’s, it shares the extended three-year warranty with the Badger 500, providing extra coverage for customers.

This exclusivity means that it might not be as available as the others but can be the perfect choice if you prefer shopping at Lowe’s or stumble on a sale or bundle deal. The 5XL appeals to buyers wanting dependable performance with the added security of a lengthier warranty from a trusted retailer.

Comparison of Badger 5 with Badger 500 & Badger 5XL

Feature	Badger 5	Badger 500	Badger 5XL
Motor Power	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor	1/2 HP Dura-Drive Induction Motor
Grinding Speed (RPM)	1725 RPM	1725 RPM	1725 RPM
Feed Type	Continuous Feed	Continuous Feed	Continuous Feed
Grinding Chamber Capacity	26 oz	26 oz	26 oz
Overall Dimensions (HxW)	11.5 in x 6.31 in	11.5 in x 6.31 in	11.5 in x 6.31 in
Mounting System	3-bolt mount	3-bolt mount	3-bolt mount
Construction Materials	Galvanized Steel	Galvanized Steel	Galvanized Steel
Noise Insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation	Basic, no advanced sound insulation
Power Cord Included	No (sold separately)	No (sold separately)	No (sold separately)
Reset Button	Yes	Yes	Yes
Hex Hole for Manual Rotation	Yes	Yes	Yes
Warranty	2-year in-home warranty	3-year in-home warranty	3-year in-home warranty
Exclusive Retailer	Available across multiple retailers	Exclusive to Home Depot	Exclusive to Lowe’s

Detailed Feature Comparison

Motor Power & Grinding Performance

All three models use a 1/2 horsepower Dura-Drive induction motor that spins at 1725 RPM, a solid specification for handling typical food waste such as vegetable peels, egg shells, and small bones. This means performance is consistent across the board, delivering enough grinding power to prevent jams and ensure smooth operation day after day. While not designed for heavy-duty commercial use, this motor suits the average household perfectly. This shared motor technology simplifies maintenance and replacement parts.

Chamber Size & Build

Each model’s grinding chamber is constructed from galvanized steel, offering durability and resistance suitable for everyday kitchen waste disposal. The chamber size is sufficient for the volume of food waste generally processed in typical homes without frequent clogging or backups. While galvanized steel is cost-effective and sturdy, it is not as corrosion-resistant as stainless steel found in higher-end disposals, so regular maintenance and proper use will help extend the lifespan. Overall, the build emphasizes solid reliability and value.

Noise Level

User experience and reported noise levels suggest all three Badger models operate within a similar sound range. While they are not the quietest disposals on the market, their noise is generally manageable and comparable to standard garbage disposals. None of these models feature advanced sound insulation technology found in premium versions, so expect typical disposal noise during use. However, most users find the sound reasonable enough not to disrupt a busy kitchen environment.

Installation & Compatibility

Thanks to the widely-used InSinkErator Quick Lock mounting system, these models share nearly identical installation procedures. This means they can be installed without specialized tools and generally fit seamlessly under the majority of standard U.S. kitchen sinks. Additionally, interchanging these models requires minimal or no changes to existing plumbing, a big advantage if you’re replacing an older unit. The quick-lock system simplifies installation, saving plumbers and DIYers both time and effort.

Size & Fit

Compact dimensions are a crucial factor for kitchens with limited under-sink space. The Badger 5, 500, and 5XL each measure about 6.3 inches in diameter and 12.6 inches tall, making them an excellent fit for most cabinets. These measurements ensure they will comfortably fit even in tighter installations, allowing room for other plumbing components. Whether replacing an old model or installing new, their relatively small size supports easy integration without demanding expensive remodeling.

Durability

The galvanized steel construction provides good durability for consistent daily use, capable of withstanding wear and tear typical to garbage disposals. However, compared to stainless steel chambers in higher-end units, galvanized steel may be more prone to corrosion over the long term, especially if exposed to moisture and acidic waste. Still, for their price range, these Badger models strike a solid balance between longevity and affordability. Regular maintenance and correct use will maximize their service life.

Warranty & Support

When it comes to warranty, the Badger 500 and 5XL models offer an extra year of coverage with a three-year warranty, while the classic Badger 5 has a two-year warranty. That additional year on the exclusives can be valuable if you want more assurance after purchase. Remember to register your garbage disposal online to access full manufacturer support and protection. The extended warranty period often reflects the retailer’s confidence in the product and benefits customers looking to avoid unexpected repair costs.

Real Differences vs. Similarities

True Distinctions

The primary differences among these three Badger models boil down to retail branding and warranty length rather than performance. Labeling and packaging vary, with the Badger 500 and 5XL being exclusive to Home Depot and Lowe’s respectively, influencing availability. The warranty extension of one year for these exclusives is meaningful, offering greater peace of mind for buyers. Price variations exist too, often reflecting store promotions, geographic region, and retailer pricing strategies.

What’s Identical?

Internally, these models share the same motor, grinder assembly, and chamber design, which means grinding power and efficiency are consistent across the board. Their sizes and Quick Lock installation systems are fully interchangeable, making any swap or upgrade straightforward. Regardless of model, all are designed for the same range of typical household scraps, delivering equivalent performance with no meaningful functional disparity.

Interchangeability

Thanks to the uniform design and mounting system, swapping one Badger model for another is generally hassle-free and involves zero or minimal plumbing modifications. Whether upgrading from a Badger 5 to a 500 or changing to the 5XL, the process is essentially plug-and-play. This compatibility factor is a huge plus for homeowners who want flexibility in purchasing and are concerned about complicated installations or costly plumber visits.

Pros & Cons of Each Model

Badger 5

Badger 500

Badger 5XL

Pricing and Where to Buy

You can typically find the Badger 5 priced between $95 and $120, making it one of the most affordable disposals on the market and available at many major appliance retailers including Amazon, Best Buy, and regional hardware stores. The Badger 500 sells for $110 to $130 but is strictly a Home Depot exclusive; expect to find deals mostly on Home Depot’s website and in-store promotions.

The Badger 5XL ranges from $120 to $140 and is sold only through Lowe’s, both online and in their brick-and-mortar locations. To get the best price, watch for major holiday sales, clearance events, or bundle promotions. Signing up for retailer newsletters or loyalty programs can also unlock exclusive rebates or coupons.

Which Badger Model Should You Choose?

If your primary goal is keeping costs low and you are comfortable with a shorter warranty, the original Badger 5 remains a solid buy and a staple in many homes. However, if an extra year of warranty coverage matters to you and the price difference is manageable, consider the Badger 500 or 5XL. Choosing between these two often comes down to which store you prefer: Home Depot or Lowe’s. Regardless of choice, all three models cater well to the needs of a moderate-use household, providing reliable and consistent performance for everyday kitchen waste disposal.

Further Reading:
Moen EX75C vs Badger 900: Which Garbage Disposal Is Right for You?
Badger 1 Vs. Badger 5 – Detailed Comparison With Installation Guide
Moen vs. InSinkErator: Major Differences and Similarities
Waste King vs. InSinkErator: Comprehensive Garbage Disposal Comparison

Conclusion

Selecting the perfect garbage disposal from the Badger series really depends on where you shop and how much value you place on warranty length rather than differences in performance. If warranty duration and retailer support are priorities, the Badger 500 and 5XL at Home Depot and Lowe’s respectively are excellent picks. Otherwise, the Badger 5 delivers equally solid grinding power and build quality for a more budget-conscious consumer.

Armed with this detailed overview, you can confidently choose a unit that fits your kitchen, budget, and convenience preferences—ensuring a cleaner, more efficient cooking and cleanup experience for years to come.